Local Government Law Bulletin
November 18, 2026
Benjamin E. Anema

Mind the Gavel: Public Comment and the First Amendment

Municipalities need clear, effective rules of procedure to conduct the public’s business, particularly when meetings become contentious. Public comment is part of that process, not a substitute for an orderly meeting. Municipalities have substantial authority to structure public comment through reasonable, viewpoint-neutral rules governing the number and placement of comment periods, speaker time limits, appropriate relevancy requirements, and objectively disruptive conduct. Carefully drafted and consistently enforced rules protect the public body’s ability to complete its agenda while preserving the public’s lawful opportunity to comment. Municipalities can and often should update those rules when existing procedures no longer meet their needs. The key is to regulate the process and disruptive conduct, not to regulate on the basis of agreeing or disagreeing with a speaker’s viewpoint.

A recent case from Maine, Blanchard v Augusta Bd of Ed, ___ F Supp 3d ___ (D Me, 2026) (Case No. 1:26-cv-00049-SDN), illustrates why the language and enforcement of public comment rules matter. In that case, Mr. Blanchard repeatedly used the Augusta Board of Education’s public comment period to criticize Board members and school officials. He called officials “soft beta males,” “sheep,” and “communists,” wore a shirt advocating that a principal be fired, placed a Chinese flag on the Board’s desk, and accused school officials of pushing “propaganda.” In response, the Board repeatedly invoked its public comment policy stating that “[s]peakers are not permitted to share gossip, make defamatory comments, or use abusive or vulgar language.” The Chair also barred comments she considered “disparaging,” “negative,” “derogatory,” “rude,” or “inappropriate.” Blanchard was repeatedly interrupted or warned and was twice prevented from completing his comments. In its preliminary injunction decision, the Court concluded that although “defamatory comments” fall outside the protection of the First Amendment, the Board’s prohibitions on “gossip” and “abusive or vulgar language” were likely unconstitutional. According to the Court, those prohibitions subjectively restricted protected speech based on its content or offensiveness, invited arbitrary enforcement and viewpoint discrimination, and swept in criticism directly relevant to school business rather than targeting objectively disruptive conduct. Although the Court’s decision is not binding in Michigan, it relied on U.S. Supreme Court rulings that are applicable in Michigan. Blanchard therefore provides a useful drafting lesson: focus restrictions on objective standards and conduct, not subjective judgments about a speaker’s criticism.

For Michigan municipalities, the authority to regulate meetings must be exercised consistently with the Open Meetings Act and any other applicable requirements. The Act permits a person to address a meeting under rules established and recorded by the public body. MCL 15.263(5). Municipalities may establish reasonable speaker time limits and designated public comment periods, and may consider consolidating two comment periods into one, provided the resulting procedures preserve the legally required opportunity to address the body and comply with any applicable hearing requirements. Appropriate relevancy requirements should be tailored to the public body’s business and the nature of the proceeding. Clearly announced, uniformly applied procedures help the chair enforce those rules and keep the meeting on track.

A public comment policy should therefore employ objective standards and apply equally to praise and criticism. The practical lesson from Blanchard is to distinguish protected criticism from conduct that interferes with the meeting. Officials should not treat comments as disruptive merely because they consider them offensive, rude, or inappropriate. Definite time limits and rules directed at actual disruption provide a firmer basis for meeting management than subjective prohibitions on “gossip” or “abusive or vulgar language.”

Municipalities need not choose between effective meeting management and lawful public comment. Clear, legally defensible rules protect the public body’s ability to conduct its business while preserving the public’s lawful opportunity to comment. When problems arise with meeting management, municipalities should review and, where appropriate, update their rules of procedure, with attention to both careful drafting and consistent, viewpoint-neutral enforcement.

If your municipality needs assistance drafting, updating, or reviewing its rules of procedure for public comment, please contact a lawyer in our Local Government Practice Group.

SHARE:

In the LEAD (logo) – Michigan Lawyers Weekly Best Legacy Law Firms